Lock in $6.99/TB by EOY. > Learn more

VMware vs Proxmox Backup Requirements: A Practical Comparison

BLOGS

Virtualization makes infrastructure easier to provision and manage, but backing up virtual machines still requires careful planning.

VMware and Proxmox use different architectures and management interfaces, which means backup requirements can vary between environments. MSPs moving clients from one platform to another also need to understand how backup, storage, recovery, and operational workflows change.

The right backup strategy should account for the hypervisor, virtual machine configuration, storage architecture, recovery objectives, and available backup tools.

Why virtualization backup requirements differ

A virtual machine is more than its virtual disk.

A useful VM backup may need to include:

  • Virtual disks
  • Configuration
  • Snapshots or checkpoints where applicable
  • Application data
  • Operating system state
  • Network configuration
  • Other metadata required for recovery

The backup platform also needs an appropriate method for accessing the hypervisor and reading VM data without unnecessary production disruption.

VMware backup requirements

Comet’s VMware vSphere backup integrates directly with vCenter Server or an ESXi host. It creates a snapshot of the selected VM, streams the required files through its chunking engine, and then removes the snapshot from the host.

The backup includes VM configuration files, VMDK disks, and other required files.

Environment requirements

Comet’s current VMware documentation lists vSphere 6.7 or later as a server requirement, while the desktop client requires Windows x86_64 and network access to the target ESXi or vCenter environment.

The backup system also requires appropriate VMware permissions to create and remove snapshots, access virtual machine disks, and browse required datastore information.

Performance considerations

Large VM disks can generate significant network traffic during backup.

Comet recommends placing the backup software close to the ESXi cluster or host for best performance. Changed Block Tracking can also reduce the amount of data that needs to be processed after the initial backup.

Proxmox backup requirements

Comet’s Proxmox solution supports Proxmox VE virtual machines and containers. The current Comet Proxmox solution requires the agent to be on the same network as the target Proxmox cluster and supports Proxmox VE 8.x or higher.

This is important for MSPs planning migrations because the backup environment must be evaluated alongside the Proxmox infrastructure.

Proxmox backup workflows can also use snapshot-based methods and Changed Block Tracking where supported.

VMware vs Proxmox: Key backup differences

RequirementVMwareProxmox
HypervisorVMware vSphereProxmox VE
Backup connectionvCenter or ESXiProxmox cluster
VM supportvSphere VMsProxmox VMs
Container supportNot applicable in the same wayProxmox containers
Changed Block TrackingSupportedSupported
Network requirementSame network as target environmentSame network as target cluster
Recovery optionsVM and file-level workflowsVM and cross-platform recovery options

Recovery capabilities

Recovery planning should be evaluated before selecting a backup platform.

A backup that is easy to create but difficult to restore may not satisfy the client’s RTO.

Comet Backup supports VMware recovery workflows and can restore virtual machine components for reimport into VMware environments.

For Proxmox, Comet supports cross-platform recovery, including restoring backups to Proxmox, VMware, or Hyper-V environments.

That capability can be particularly useful for MSPs managing virtualization migrations.

Storage efficiency and automation

Both environments can generate large amounts of VM data, making storage efficiency important.

Comet uses chunking, compression, and deduplication to avoid repeatedly storing identical data.

Backup scheduling, retention, and storage policies should still be configured according to the workload rather than the hypervisor alone.

Which platform is the right fit?

The choice between VMware and Proxmox should not be made based solely on backup requirements.

Consider:

  • Existing infrastructure
  • Licensing costs
  • Staff expertise
  • Client requirements
  • Application compatibility
  • Migration plans
  • Backup and recovery requirements
  • Long-term operational costs

For MSPs, backup portability can also be important.

A provider managing clients across different virtualization platforms may benefit from a backup solution that can support multiple hypervisors through a consistent management workflow.

FAQs

Are VMware and Proxmox backups the same?

No. Although both protect virtual machines, the backup process, hypervisor interfaces, permissions, and recovery workflows differ.

Does Comet support VMware backups?

Yes. Comet supports VMware vSphere backups through vCenter Server or ESXi connections.

Does Comet support Proxmox?

Yes. Comet supports Proxmox VE virtual machines and containers. Its current Proxmox solution requires Proxmox VE 8.x or higher.

Can Proxmox backups be restored to other hypervisors?

Comet’s Proxmox solution supports restoring backups to Proxmox, VMware, or Hyper-V environments.

Does Changed Block Tracking reduce backup requirements?

CBT can reduce the amount of changed data that needs to be processed after the initial backup, improving backup efficiency.

VMware and Proxmox have different backup requirements, but the underlying principle remains the same: the backup architecture should support the client’s recovery objectives without creating unnecessary operational overhead. MSPs should evaluate backup connectivity, storage, performance, retention, and recovery before committing to a virtualization strategy.

Tagged:

STAY UPDATED WITH COMET INSIGHTS

Get the latest updates on cloud backup trends, MSP strategies, and Comet feature releases — straight to your inbox.